What Halloween 2026 taught us about bold, brand-safe marketing

Share

Halloween gave brands something worth celebrating this year: happier comment sections.

Across 329 brands and the week leading up to Halloween, sentiment peaked on October 31. Total sentiment climbed from a weekly averageof 58 to 62, positivity reached 47%, and negativity dropped to 18%.

But a playful audience doesn’t mean every creative swing will land. The same comment sections celebrating clever costumes and unexpected brand collaborations can quickly turn when a joke misses or an experience falls short.

We looked at how brands approached Halloween 2026, what audiences had to say, and what marketers can take into brand safe holiday marketing this season.

Three brands that got it right

The brands that leaned into Halloween with a clear idea came out wellahead of average. Every brand below beat the all-brand benchmark on total sentiment, and most kept negativity well under it.

Reese’s: give people something to talk about

Reese’s teamed up with Zillow to crown East Dudley Ave in Westfield, NJ, “America’s Trick-or-Treatiest Street” then threw it a party with a Reese’s truck, decor and photo props. Online, it ran a “31 days, 31 reasons” countdown and a simple “tell us your Reese’s pick” post.

 It paid off. Reese’s comments earned a total sentiment score of 74 for the week (our 0–100 score across every comment, before moderation). That’s 28% above the all-brand average of 58, with just 10% negativity against an average of 23%.

That simple prompt was the star, generating 189 comments, more than any other Reese’s post. Across the broader conversation, “I’ll take them all” appeared 349 times. Reese’s Halloween-themed feed posts were 72% positive with a total sentiment of 83, the highest of any content set in our study.

The one soft spot was the real-world event. Comments on the Dudley Ave posts were 27% negative, compared with just 5% for the rest of Reese’s content. Most complaints focused on long lines and houses running out of candy by 6 p.m. The campaign generated excitement, but the experience struggled to keep up with demand.

Pringles: a bold joke that fits the brand

In mid-October, Pringles invited die-hard fans to “prove your love” for a chance to win a can-shaped urn and an “afterlifetime” supply of chips. The concept was unconventional, but the audience response showed it was a fit for the brand.

Pringles’ comments scored a total sentiment of 68 for the week, 17% above the all-brand average of 58. Pringles’ negativity was just 8% for the week, about a third of the average, and fans were still bringing up the urn weeks later. Its Halloween-week content continued the playful approach with witch-themed recipes and lighthearted captions.

The humor worked because it was unmistakably Pringles. The campaign leaned into the brand’s playful personality, giving fans something unexpected to talk about without making anyone else the punchline.

PetSmart: built for its audience, on and offline

PetSmart’s “Thrills & Chills” collection put pets in costumes like Michael Myers and Chucky, backed by free in-store pet trick-or-treating and a “Meet the Spooky Pets” experience.

It was the cleanest Halloween in our group. PetSmart’s Halloween total sentiment hit 74, 19% above the all-brand Halloween-day average of 62, with just 10% negativity. Comment volume rose 35% over its weekday baseline, and weekend negativity fell from 18% to 13%.

The horror-movie references gave familiar pet costumes a playful twist, while in-store activities extended the experience beyond social. PetSmart showed how brands can build on what their audience already loves and give them more reasons to engage.

When Halloween goes wrong

Not every Halloween moment earned a positive reaction. Martha Stewart faced criticism after sharing a costume depicting someone experiencing homelessness, with a sign asking for food. The post, which also promoted her candle collection, quickly attracted backlash.

Stewart removed the original post and later apologized, but the conversation continued. Our analysis found that negativity on her account climbed from 11% to 56% in just 48 hours.

The reaction showed how quickly a creative decision can overshadow the content or product it was meant to promote. It also reinforced an important lesson for brands: deleting a post doesn’t delete the conversation. When something misses, how a brand responds matters just as much as the original decision.

Brand safe holiday marketing

Halloween 2026 showed that audiences respond to brands willing to have some fun. But the strongest campaigns also understood their audiences, delivered on expectations, and had a plan for the conversations that followed.

  1. Give people a reason to participate. Reese’s biggest comment driver was a simple question. Build opportunities for your audience to contribute, share preferences, and join the conversation rather than simply react to another campaign announcement.

  2. Take creative risks that fit your brand. Pringles leaned into dark humor because its audience already recognizes that personality. The most effective creative ideas build on what people know and love about a brand.

  3. Consider who is on the receiving end of the joke. Martha Stewart’s Halloween backlash showed how quickly humor can turn into criticism. Before publishing, consider how the idea might be interpreted beyond its intended audience.

  4. Make sure the experience delivers on the promise. Reese’s created excitement, but long lines and limited supplies contributed to negative reactions. Real-world activations need the same attention to planning and audience experience as the content promoting them.

  5. Prepare your comment section before the campaign goes live. Cultural moments bring more attention, but also more opportunities for harmful comments, spam, and criticism. Our analysis found that moderation could improve visible sentiment across every brand studied, with a 13% lift across the broader dataset. Monitor conversations in real time, prioritize meaningful responses, and have a plan for unexpected reactions.

Next up – the holidays

With Black Friday and the December holidays around the corner, brands have another opportunity to turn cultural moments into meaningful engagement. The lessons from Halloween are worth carrying forward: understand your audience, take creative risks that fit your brand, and prepare for the conversations that follow.

The creative idea gets people talking. How brands manage the conversation determines what happens next.

Get a demo

Want to see how your brand’s comments performed this Halloween, or prepare your moderation strategy for the holiday rush?

Latest articles

Fashion Month brought a modest lift in comments, but the biggest conversations weren’t about the clothes at all. We analyzed 265,617 comments across New York, London, Milan, and Paris to see which brands drove the conversation, where sentiment peaked, and what brands can take into next season.
6M comments arrive as questions every month. Answers already exist in your brand knowledge. See how Respond’s Expert Agent puts them to work.
News

Subscribe to our newsletter to get content (that is actually useful) delivered to your inbox.