In 2024, brand reputation became a high-wire act. Social media backlash is more of a guarantee than a risk. The reason? Brands forgot one simple truth: the story isn’t just told by you or your campaigns—it’s also told in the conversations happening around them.
Let’s talk about what we learned and how 2025 can be different.
2024: The Year Comment Sections Set the Agenda
Social media is no longer just a platform for broadcasting. It’s a forum, a stage, a megaphone for your audience. And if you’re not managing that stage, someone else will.
Just ask Kraft Heinz, whose ketchup “smiles” ad got slammed for racial insensitivity. The comments were swift, cutting, and loud (highlighting the importance of scrutinizing campaigns through diverse lenses to avoid cultural missteps). Or Bud Light, which stumbled through yet another year of backlash to their partnership with Dylan Mulvaney without reclaiming the narrative. Or even Target, caught between two opposing forces (lean in or lean back) during Pride Month, watching the debate play out in their own digital spaces.
Even Apple—the master of control—got burned when its ad celebrating the iPad featured a hydraulic press destroying creative tools turned into a critique of creativity itself. And then there’s Jaguar, whose rebrand activated everyone’s cultural opinions, with comment sections labeling the campaign “woke” and “bonkers”, sparking intense debates.
The problem wasn’t just the missteps. It was the way the conversations spiraled—unmanaged, unmoderated, and unchecked.
2025: A Different Playbook
If 2024 was the year brands lost control of their stories, 2025 is the year to take them back. Not by censoring, but by participating. Here’s how:
- Moderate the Space Where Stories Happen
Your comment sections aren’t an afterthought. They’re where your customers are shaping your brand in real-time. Toxic comments, spam, or misinformation? They erode trust faster than any single ad campaign can build it.
- Respond Like a Human, Not a PR Machine
Ignored comments breed frustration. Canned responses breed cynicism. Be present. Be thoughtful. Own the hard conversations.
- Spot the Signals Before the Noise
Social media isn’t a firehose—it’s a radar. Look for early trends in what people are saying. Those comments that seem small now? They’re tomorrow’s headline if left unaddressed.
- Turn Your Critics Into Collaborators
The best feedback can sometimes come from the loudest voices. Engage. Learn. Invite your audience to help shape the story.
- Celebrate the Comments That Matter
Not every comment is a complaint. Some are insights. Some are opportunities. Some are the exact conversations that show your brand is doing something right. Find those and amplify them.
The Opportunity in 2025
In 2024, brands treated comment sections like an afterthought. In 2025, they can be a competitive edge. A place where trust is built, loyalty is earned, and insights are uncovered.
Your comment sections are your brand’s mirror. They show you not just what people think, but how they feel. And if you’re willing to look closely, they’ll also show you what to do next.
The brands that succeed in 2025 won’t be the ones with the flashiest campaigns. They’ll be the ones who listen better, respond faster, and build real connections in the spaces that matter.
Because the truth is, your brand isn’t what you say it is. It’s what they say it is.
Let’s make 2025 the year brands get it right.
What Brands Got Wrong On Social Media In 2024 (and How to Fix It in 2025)
Share
In 2024, brand reputation became a high-wire act. Social media backlash is more of a guarantee than a risk. The reason? Brands forgot one simple truth: the story isn’t just told by you or your campaigns—it’s also told in the conversations happening around them.
Let’s talk about what we learned and how 2025 can be different.
2024: The Year Comment Sections Set the Agenda
Social media is no longer just a platform for broadcasting. It’s a forum, a stage, a megaphone for your audience. And if you’re not managing that stage, someone else will.
Just ask Kraft Heinz, whose ketchup “smiles” ad got slammed for racial insensitivity. The comments were swift, cutting, and loud (highlighting the importance of scrutinizing campaigns through diverse lenses to avoid cultural missteps). Or Bud Light, which stumbled through yet another year of backlash to their partnership with Dylan Mulvaney without reclaiming the narrative. Or even Target, caught between two opposing forces (lean in or lean back) during Pride Month, watching the debate play out in their own digital spaces.
Even Apple—the master of control—got burned when its ad celebrating the iPad featured a hydraulic press destroying creative tools turned into a critique of creativity itself. And then there’s Jaguar, whose rebrand activated everyone’s cultural opinions, with comment sections labeling the campaign “woke” and “bonkers”, sparking intense debates.
The problem wasn’t just the missteps. It was the way the conversations spiraled—unmanaged, unmoderated, and unchecked.
2025: A Different Playbook
If 2024 was the year brands lost control of their stories, 2025 is the year to take them back. Not by censoring, but by participating. Here’s how:
Your comment sections aren’t an afterthought. They’re where your customers are shaping your brand in real-time. Toxic comments, spam, or misinformation? They erode trust faster than any single ad campaign can build it.
Ignored comments breed frustration. Canned responses breed cynicism. Be present. Be thoughtful. Own the hard conversations.
Social media isn’t a firehose—it’s a radar. Look for early trends in what people are saying. Those comments that seem small now? They’re tomorrow’s headline if left unaddressed.
The best feedback can sometimes come from the loudest voices. Engage. Learn. Invite your audience to help shape the story.
Not every comment is a complaint. Some are insights. Some are opportunities. Some are the exact conversations that show your brand is doing something right. Find those and amplify them.
The Opportunity in 2025
In 2024, brands treated comment sections like an afterthought. In 2025, they can be a competitive edge. A place where trust is built, loyalty is earned, and insights are uncovered.
Your comment sections are your brand’s mirror. They show you not just what people think, but how they feel. And if you’re willing to look closely, they’ll also show you what to do next.
The brands that succeed in 2025 won’t be the ones with the flashiest campaigns. They’ll be the ones who listen better, respond faster, and build real connections in the spaces that matter.
Because the truth is, your brand isn’t what you say it is. It’s what they say it is.
Let’s make 2025 the year brands get it right.
Let’s talk.
Latest articles
Your Summer Reading List: Five Things Your Comment Section Is Trying to Tell You
Social Media Got Louder. It Didn’t Get More Social.
Swimwear, Sunscreen, And Scrutiny: How The Comment Section Has Become Part Of The Shopping Experience
News
Subscribe to our newsletter to get content (that is actually useful) delivered to your inbox.